Israeli Forces Killed 15 Rescuers in Rafah

Watchtower · Public-record investigation & remembrance

Rifaat Radwan. Mustafa Khafaja. Ezz El-Din Shaat. Saleh Muammar. Muhammad Bahloul. Ashraf Abu Libda. Muhammad al-Hila. Raed al-Sharif. Zuhair al-Farra. Samir al-Bahapsa. Ibrahim al-Maghari. Fouad al-Jamal. Youssef Khalifa. Anwar al-Attar. Kamal Shahtout.

These are the fifteen people this report remembers. Eight worked with the Palestine Red Crescent Society, six with Palestinian Civil Defence, and one with UNRWA. Israeli forces killed them in Rafah on March 23, 2025. They had names, relationships, responsibilities and futures. Their service deserves to be recorded with the same care as the evidence of their deaths.

Rifaat’s recovered phone helped expose what happened. Other workers’ calls, survivors’ accounts, medical examinations and recovery records widened the picture. A September 2025 UN Commission finding and a February 2026 joint forensic investigation describe intentional killing. In August 2026, Israel itself ordered a criminal investigation. None of that gives a family back the person missing from its table.

Content note: This report discusses shootings, bodies, medical findings, detention and bereavement. It does not reproduce graphic images. Source review: November 14, 2026. This is a review of published evidence and testimony, with identified editorial judgments. Watchtower did not conduct fieldwork, interview these families, obtain the complete military case file or independently rerun the forensic models.

1. Fifteen people, several attacks

The location is the Tel al-Sultan area of Rafah, in the southern Gaza Strip. This was a sequence of attacks on vehicles and people over the course of a morning. The famous recording captures one part of that sequence. It does not show every death.

The PRCS’s March 30 announcement named its eight dead colleagues. OCHA’s contemporary recovery record establishes the wider fifteen-person toll: eight PRCS workers, six Civil Defence workers and one UNRWA employee. One Civil Defence body was retrieved on March 27; the remaining fourteen were recovered on March 30. The dates of recovery should not be confused with independently established times of death.

The distinction matters to the remembrance. Kamal Shahtout’s separate journey in a UN vehicle must not disappear inside a generic account of an ambulance convoy. The first crew, the people sent to find them, and the later arrivals each deserve an account of what happened to them. Responsibility becomes clearer when the sequence is reconstructed carefully.

2. Rifaat Radwan, before the recording

Rifaat Anwar Suleiman Radwan joined the PRCS in 2022. His father remembered a university graduate who wanted to keep studying, support his family and build a steadier future. He also remembered the emotional cost of the work: Rifaat sometimes cried at night over the wounded people he had treated.

Before the final mission, he came home to change a bloodied shirt. His father recalled the smile he left with. “I was proud of my son even before the video went viral,” he told the PRCS. The recording preserved evidence. His father’s words preserve the person who chose to help. PRCS remembrance, May 6, 2025.

A person should not have to record his own killing to make the world examine it. Rifaat had already spent years doing work worth remembering. The camera became part of his legacy because the people with guns created a situation in which evidence had to outlive its witness.

3. Remembering the other seven Red Crescent workers

The following memories come from the PRCS’s individual profiles and its published interviews with relatives. They describe lives before the final mission. English spellings vary between records; the linked sources preserve their original renderings.

Mustafa Mohammad Hamad Khafaja. He devoted a quarter-century to humanitarian service, according to the PRCS. He trained in emergency medical services in Khan Younis and began working with the society in 2000. At home, he was the father of an only son, Muhammad, whose arrival he and his wife had waited years for. Muhammad remembered his father as kind and helpful, trusted by neighbors and colleagues. Mustafa had survived earlier attacks and injuries. The years he spent carrying people toward help belong in the record of what Israel took from his family and community. Mustafa’s remembrance.

Ezz El-Din Ahmad Shaat. He began his PRCS service in 2000 and was the father of six children. His wife, Um Ahmad, remembered how carefully he separated professional responsibilities from private life: the ambulance was for its work, and the uniform was worn on duty. He would not take the family for rides in the ambulance or wear his EMT clothing to social events. After difficult shifts, he tried to spare his children the details of what he had seen. Those small rules reveal a serious man who respected the emblem and the people who needed it. Ezz El-Din’s remembrance.

Saleh Mahmoud Hussein Muammar. He began volunteering with the PRCS in late 2008. He held a business degree and trained in emergency medical services. A father of five, he had already lost three brothers—Hamza, Anas and Mohammad—in an Israeli airstrike in 2014, according to the society’s family remembrance. His wife suffered a devastating injury when their tent was bombed. Saleh had himself survived gunshot wounds during rescue work and returned to duty. His brother Hussein remembered a compassionate man who hurried to help without expecting anything in return. His family was carrying grief long before this final loss. Saleh’s remembrance.

Muhammad Subhi Mahmoud Bahloul. He was a father of five, a trained nurse and an emergency medical technician. Just a month before his death, he completed another degree, in business administration at Al-Quds Open University. His youngest child had been born on January 1, 2025. The PRCS remembers a father trying to secure a future for children he scarcely had time to see between missions. His brother Ali recalled his generosity and willingness to rush toward the wounded. Muhammad understood that a shift might take his life. He continued to answer calls for help. Muhammad Bahloul’s remembrance.

Ashraf Nasser Abdel Hai Abu Libda. He had a mathematics degree from Al-Aqsa University and began volunteering with the PRCS in 2021. He married shortly before the war and still spoke of himself as a newlywed. During the temporary ceasefire, he and his wife welcomed their son, Wi’am. His brother Sami remembered the happiness that arrival brought and the family’s hope that the calm would last. Ashraf wanted to watch his child grow and build a future with his wife. Displacement did not end his humanitarian work. His son deserved years together with him. Ashraf’s remembrance.

Muhammad Hasan al-Hila. He grew up watching his father, Hasan, work as a PRCS emergency medical technician. As a child, he played at being a medic; later he trained at the society’s institute in Khan Younis and joined its teams in 2022. His father remembered a gentle son who hoped to marry and who put aside money from his small volunteer stipend for each of his four sisters. His family’s memories make visible a young man planning a life and looking after people close to him. He chose the same work his father did: helping strangers through emergencies. Muhammad al-Hila’s remembrance.

Raed Ibraheem Khalil al-Sharif. He joined the PRCS during the 2018 Great March of Return demonstrations, according to its remembrance. He helped document the teams’ humanitarian work through photographs and reports. The youngest of four brothers, he brought home accounts of difficult missions and sometimes reviewed images during short breaks with his family. His father remembered his love for his late mother and how he considered his good deeds a gift for her soul. Raed’s work helped other people’s suffering be seen. His own name and service deserve that same care in the public record. Raed’s remembrance.

4. Remembering the six Civil Defence workers

Palestinian Civil Defence’s March 28 public statement identifies the mission leader and five colleagues who were still missing at that point, with their duties. The subsequent recovery record confirms six Civil Defence deaths. The published personal record is uneven. Where this review could not substantiate a family detail or private memory, it leaves that detail open rather than inventing a biography.

Zuhair Abdul Hamid al-Farra drove the fire truck. Journalist Mohammed al-Jamal, who interviewed him before his death, later described a rescuer continuing to work despite relatives’ deaths, the destruction of family homes and repeated close calls on missions. His interview preserves a record of endurance while Zuhair was alive. Al-Araby Al-Jadeed’s investigation.

Samir Yahya al-Bahapsa was a firefighter officer. His employer’s record places his name beside that responsibility. Remembering him includes recognizing the work he was there to perform and the people who depended on a fire crew reaching them.

Ibrahim Nabil al-Maghari was also a firefighter officer. He belongs in this account as an individual, with a name that can be searched, preserved and carried forward. The absence of an extensive English-language profile does not diminish his life.

Fouad Ibrahim al-Jamal drove a Civil Defence ambulance. His colleague Ahmad Ridwan remembered a mission when Israeli tanks were advancing and a fire truck needed to be moved. Although driving that vehicle was unfamiliar work for him, Fouad took its wheel, with Anwar al-Attar beside him, and brought it through gunfire to safety. Ridwan’s memory, published by Safa, records a man preserving equipment other rescuers depended on. The account does not date that earlier mission.

Youssef Rassem Khalifa was an ambulance officer. In the same published interview, Ahmad Ridwan remembered him among colleagues whose work was answering people in distress, including children and women. His name deserves to survive the compression of a headline’s casualty count.

Anwar Abdel Hamid al-Attar led the Civil Defence mission. In August 2026, Reuters interviewed his wife, Ghada, in the family’s tent in Khan Younis. Their daughter held and kissed his vest. Ghada described him as the family’s support and spoke of the pain of their daughter asking where her father was. She questioned the delay in opening an investigation and said she did not trust the army to deliver justice. For his family, the loss remained daily and intimate.

Their employer’s public channel record preserves the names in Arabic. Transliteration differences should prompt careful cross-checking, never the accidental disappearance of a person from the list.

5. Remembering Kamal Shahtout

Kamal Shahtout worked with UNRWA for more than twenty years and left a wife and children. In a May 28, 2025 statement, Commissioner-General Philippe Lazzarini said Kamal left his Rafah home wearing a UN vest and driving a clearly marked UN vehicle. The agency lost contact with him within an hour. His body was found on March 30, near the other workers’ burial site. UNRWA described fatal blows to the back of his skull and called his death a summary execution.

Those are the employer’s stated findings and characterization. They demand investigation into his treatment and death, including what happened after he encountered Israeli forces. Kamal’s name must remain visible as the UN colleague among the fifteen. Two decades of work and a family’s loss cannot be reduced to a vehicle appearing near the end of someone else’s chronology.

6. The emergency mission and the footage

The PRCS’s April 7 statement describes an ambulance sent to casualties after a home was bombed, followed by crews searching for the missing team. It identifies Rifaat’s recovered footage as showing clearly marked ambulances, their emergency lights operating, approaching the site of the earlier attack. It also records later attacks and difficulty obtaining access to search for colleagues.

The significance is concrete. The visual evidence contradicts the initial public description of vehicles approaching without emergency signals. The markings and lights were part of how these workers identified themselves. Their visibility is an evidentiary question about what armed personnel could see and recognize.

The PRCS characterized the attacks as deliberate and called for an independent international investigation. Its role as the workers’ employer gives it direct institutional knowledge, while its allegations still need examination against the recordings, survivor evidence and other records. A recording can expose a false explanation without, on its own, resolving every question about every soldier’s knowledge or orders.

Rifaat’s recording contains his faith and fear in his own voice. This report does not manufacture a polished final speech from viral translations. The original recording and the analyses linked below deserve careful, dignified attention. Readers should be able to understand the case without being required to watch a man die.

7. What the joint forensic investigation found

Earshot and Forensic Architecture’s joint investigation combined survivor interviews, spatial modelling, satellite imagery, Rifaat’s footage and two dispatch calls. The February 23, 2026 report counted at least 910 gunshots across three recordings, including 844 during five-and-a-half minutes in Rifaat’s video. It identified bullet-shockwave and muzzle-blast pairs in 789 of those 844 shots, supporting fire toward the camera and emergency vehicles.

The researchers inferred at least five simultaneous shooters and an advance toward the vehicles. Matching 109 gunshots synchronized Rifaat’s video with Ashraf’s call, which continued after the video ended. Their model placed a subsequent shooter approximately one to four metres from Ashraf. They concluded that aid workers were executed at close range.

These are investigative findings built partly on models and survivor testimony. They do not identify every shooter or each fatal round. The recordings capture stages across two hours, rather than continuous two-hour audio. The original report explains the evidence and assumptions.

8. Bodies, medical evidence and the limits of claims

A June 27, 2025 communication from UN independent experts adds medical detail. Forensic doctor Morris Tidball-Binz, the Special Rapporteur on extrajudicial executions, reviewed the eight PRCS workers’ autopsies. The letter reports firearm injuries as their causes of death, with most sustaining upper-body wounds, including head and neck wounds described as execution-style.

It separately reports Kamal’s body partially buried behind a dirt berm about thirty metres from the other grave. His reported autopsy attributed death to blunt-force trauma to the back of his head, with skull fractures. The experts raised the reported summary execution following detention and demanded an independent investigation. Their communication presents serious allegations and expert assessment; it is not a criminal conviction.

This evidence requires precision. The fifteen must not all be described as having died from the same weapon or in the same place.

Sky News’s independent investigation interviewed pathologist Dr Ahmed Dahair and examined satellite imagery. He said decomposition prevented his team from determining firing distance and reported no clear signs of physical restraints. A photographed wrist tie carried an information card of the type used to identify bodies; it did not establish pre-death handcuffing.

Sky’s 10:48 a.m. satellite image showed five vehicles already moved off the road but not yet crushed, challenging the account that crushing happened accidentally during removal.

Unproved restraint claims are unnecessary to condemn what the established record shows. Accurate examination protects the case from being displaced by a dispute over an assertion the evidence never settled.

9. Recovery, and the people who survived

OCHA’s April 4 recovery account describes bodies beneath sand alongside marked ambulances, a fire truck and a UN car. An ambulance emergency light marked the burial site.

The destruction of vehicles also destroys a community’s capacity to respond to the next emergency. Families who never met these fifteen workers still depended on a functioning ambulance service and Civil Defence. The consequences continued beyond the people named in this report.

Two surviving PRCS workers must be distinguished from the dead: Munther Abed and Asaad al-Nasasra. Their accounts form part of the investigative record. Asaad was detained by Israeli forces and released on April 29, 2025, according to the PRCS’s announcement. A contemporary report carrying the reunion footage corroborates that date. He was taken for medical examination after release.

Accounts published while his whereabouts were unknown must not be repeated as his current status. Neither survivor should be required to carry the entire demand for justice alone. Their testimony deserves preservation, scrutiny and protection.

10. Israel’s explanations changed

On April 2, 2025, the IDF claimed vehicles advanced suspiciously without prior coordination, headlights or emergency signals. It said an inquiry subsequently recognized ambulances and fire trucks. It also alleged that a named Hamas operative and eight others affiliated with Hamas or Palestinian Islamic Jihad were killed. The statement did not publish the underlying evidence establishing those affiliations or connect every allegation to an identified person on the fifteen-worker roster.

The April 7 update said six of those killed had been identified as Hamas members. It ordered a deeper examination through the General Staff fact-finding mechanism. Again, the brief public statement supplied no individualized evidentiary explanation for those six identifications.

In its April 20 examination, the military acknowledged its forces’ fire and described perceived threats and poor nighttime visibility. It denied executions, binding of the dead and attempted concealment. It said firing at a UN vehicle breached regulations. It characterized crushing the vehicles as wrong and identified incomplete or inaccurate reporting and other professional failures.

The IDF dismissed the Golani Reconnaissance Battalion deputy commander and reprimanded the 14th Brigade commander. The examination was submitted to the Military Advocate General. Disciplinary measures were not a criminal judgment.

The PRCS’s April 22 response rejected the affiliation allegations, challenged the military’s account of access and recovery, and demanded an independent investigation. It argued that the inquiry shielded the truth rather than establishing accountability.

Watchtower’s assessment: Allegations about affiliation require evidence about the particular person and the legal circumstances of the attack. They cannot simply be attached to a casualty total after the shooting. The original no-signals claim must be evaluated against visible signals. A corrected public account should explain how the false account arose, who supplied it and what consequences followed.

11. The UN Commission’s finding

The UN Commission’s September 2025 report, A/HRC/60/CRP.3, examines the case in paragraphs 35–44 and 47, pages 12–15.

In paragraph 44, it describes Israel’s response as lacking, erroneous and misrepresentative. It finds the video exposed a false narrative, showing clearly identified vehicles and no active gunfire before Israeli forces fired. It says it retained information concerning persons of interest and had requested the complete military report without receiving it by that report’s cutoff.

Paragraph 47 finds Israeli forces intentionally shot at first responders; the duration and extent of the firing supported the conclusion that they intended to kill. That is a serious investigative finding of intentional conduct. It is not an individual criminal conviction, and the Commission’s September 2025 account must be read alongside the later criminal-investigation decision.

12. The criminal inquiry, and what remains unanswered

On August 19, 2026, Israel announced an MPCID criminal investigation. Its statement acknowledges fifteen deaths across three shooting incidents involving ambulances, a fire truck and a UN vehicle. It also describes troops crushing vehicles and covering bodies with metal mesh. It repeats the claim that six of the dead were Hamas members.

Crucially, the military said the firing raised a reasonable suspicion of criminal misconduct and required criminal investigation. It withheld further specifics because of that inquiry. The public record therefore moved beyond the earlier account of professional failures and disciplinary action.

As of this November 14, 2026 review, we found no publicly announced Rafah-specific indictment, trial, conviction, final MPCID report or decision closing the criminal case. That is a bounded public-source finding. It does not establish that no investigative work has occurred privately.

The outstanding questions include who fired during each stage; what orders were issued; what commanders could see and hear; how survivors and wounded people were treated; what happened to Kamal after contact was lost; who authorized the handling of bodies and vehicles; and how inaccurate information entered the official public account.

Independent investigators need the complete operational logs, radio traffic, orders, available vehicle or body-camera recordings, weapons evidence, original medical material and relevant witness access. Preserving that record is urgent. An investigation announced in a statement must lead to an evidentiary process that can establish responsibility.

13. The protection the law requires

The ICRC’s customary-law study requires protection for personnel exclusively assigned to medical duties and vehicles exclusively assigned to medical transport. Protection can be lost through harmful acts outside the humanitarian function. A retrospective label does not by itself establish that these conditions were met.

The dead must be treated respectfully, their identities recorded as far as possible, and their graves marked. These duties are addressed in Rule 115 and Rule 116. Rule 158 requires investigation of alleged war crimes by a state’s own forces and prosecution where appropriate.

Applying those standards requires evidence about conduct, protected status, knowledge and intent. An internal disciplinary decision cannot settle every question of individual criminal responsibility. The duty to investigate extends beyond producing an explanation that protects an institution’s reputation.

14. Mercy, remembrance and the demand for justice

Editorial judgment: DaddyBruce95 condemns these killings and the destruction of the means of rescue. The evidence demands independent accountability for the Israeli personnel and commanders responsible. Repeatedly sending families from an official denial to a revised explanation, and then to an investigation whose outcome remains unpublished, is no substitute for justice.

On a platform shaped by faith, mercy means protecting people who go toward the wounded. God should never be used as a decoration for indifference. These workers’ own beliefs and family memories deserve respect; their suffering is not a prop for somebody else’s performance of righteousness.

Rifaat’s father was proud before the recording became famous. Ezz El-Din respected the uniform. Mustafa’s son remembered kindness. Ashraf had a young child. The Civil Defence workers had duties their community relied on. Kamal had served for decades. The evidence record must carry those human realities alongside its timestamps.

Our call is for lawful pressure: independent investigations, prosecution where evidence establishes criminal responsibility, preservation and disclosure of records, reparations, protection of witnesses and medical work, and restrictions on weapons and assistance used to commit abuses. DaddyBruce95 supports disarming Israel through peaceful legal, political, diplomatic and economic action to stop the institutional capacity for these abuses.

Readers can take peaceful action, support verified humanitarian organizations through their own official channels, and preserve links to the original evidence with their dates and context. The related Hind Rajab investigation remembers another child and the two paramedics sent to save her. These cases demand specific accountability for specific acts.

Remember all fifteen. Preserve their names. Demand the records. Hold the responsible people and institutions to account. Their families are owed more than another statement.

15. Sources, method and corrections

The links beside each passage identify the record supporting it. The eight individual PRCS profiles preserve published family testimony. Civil Defence’s channel establishes its roster and duties; OCHA records the recovery. UNRWA’s statement addresses Kamal. The joint Earshot–Forensic Architecture investigation, Sky’s independent work, UN experts’ communication and the UN Commission report have different methods and evidentiary limits. They should not be counted as independent confirmation every time they draw on the same recording or witness.

The Israeli statements are linked in dated order so readers can examine both the allegations and the changes. This report distinguishes institutional acknowledgments, witness testimony, forensic inferences, Commission findings, legal standards and editorial demands. Some original institutional pages or PDFs restrict automated access; relevant official indexed text, available original documents and preserved source records were used, with no claim of access to private files.

We have avoided unresolved ages, uncertain middle-name variants, invented private details and unverified translations of final words. Photographs of identification ties are not treated as proof of restraint. Source-review dates describe the work actually reviewed, rather than claiming every underlying record has been independently authenticated by Watchtower.

Names and links deserve correction if better evidence becomes available. To report a substantive error, use the process described in Standards & corrections. This remembrance remains open to documented additions about the fifteen lives and to material developments in the investigation. Published and source-reviewed November 14, 2026.

Previous
Previous

U.S. Forces Killed Children and Teachers at Minab School

Next
Next

Israeli Forces Killed Hind Rajab and the Paramedics Sent to Save Her